Peyton made her Off-Broadway debut as a Featured Ensemble member in I'll Say She Is: The Lost Marx Brothers Musical. The musical performed at the Connelly Theater from May 28th - July 3rd. Both the New York Times and Time Out New York deemed the show a Critics' Pick!
Theatre is Easy
"The musical’s versatile ensemble contributes to its appeal. Shea Sullivan’s lively choreography highlights the chorus’ collective talents as well as individual members’ skills; soloists Dante Adela and Peyton Lustig are especially striking in a passionate Apache dance and several dreamy ballet sequences."
"Also added in are some beautiful contemporary ballet dance numbers by the talented duo of Dante Adela and Peyton Lustig. The chorus sings and dances as an alluring Corps of angel-faced bombshells. The opening tap number alone is enough to tire the most accomplished of hoofers."
"Dante Adela and Peyton Lustig were both amazing ballet dancers in the Apache Dance and when portraying Pygmalion & Galatea."